The main terminology right here, once we learn about Ion, was epistasthai and you can techne

Socrates, Aristophanes, and you can Agathon remain about revealing tragedy and funny: “a portion of the section is actually you to Socrates was looking to persuade him or her your same man knows (epistasthai) just how to make each other comedy and you will tragedy, that somebody who is because of the craft (techne) a tragic poet was a comic poet also” (223d26).

A precise breakdown, undoubtedly, of the speeches from all of the symposiasts just who cam earlier in the day in order to Socrates

Ordinary poets usually do not write one another comedy and you will problem, because they do not write out of real information how to delete chatspin account and you can craft (techne) but from divine determination (Ion 534c56). Once they did make-out off craft and you will training, when they have been craftsmen poets, they will produce both comedy and you may disaster, since opposites will always read because of the same hobby. For this reason the comedic passion in addition to heartbreaking passion would need to be you to plus the same; as a possible together with same craft, drug, works together with each other sickness and health.

After the Symposium, Alcibiades moved off, presumably into the throng away from Bacchic revelers, whom burst with the their life since representatives of his seizing like into recognition and flattery of one’s group

Socrates confides in us just what an excellent craftsman poet would be able to create, the guy will not tell us just what he would build. Most other Platonic spokesmen was significantly more imminent. “We ourselves is poets,” the Athenian Complete stranger confides in us regarding Statutes, “who’ve into better of all of our function written an emergency that is the ideal and the finest; at the very least, our very own whole composition is actually created given that a replica of the finest and best way of living-the question and therefore we allege ‘s the truest tragedy” (817b15). Prior to in identical dialogue, the brand new Complete stranger was similarly specific this same composition, even when not a comedy, does nonetheless embody comedic degree:

An individual who is going to obtain practical expertise cant discover major things versus studying ridiculous of those, otherwise anything, for instance, as opposed to their reverse. However, if we’re going to and get virtue, actually with the a tiny size, i cannot feel really serious and you can comical too, and this is exactly why we need to discover ways to recognize exactly what is ridiculous, to eliminate being caught up from the all of our ignorance of it toward creating otherwise claiming anything ridiculous, when we don’t must. (816d5-e5)

The fresh Symposium is actually a tragedy to possess a keen analogous reasoning: it contains a replica of one element of instance a life, namely, exactly what the Protagoras terms an effective “symposium off beautiful and you will a beneficial guys” who “sample for every anyone else mettle into the mutual disagreement” because of the asking and you can answering issues (347d3348a9). This is one way Socrates reacts so you can Agathons speech. It is how Diotima converses having Socrates. It is the kind of symposium Socrates tries to lso are-establish whenever Alcibiades “satyr-play” is finished, plus the throng of Bacchic revelers has left.

In lieu of brand new Laws and regulations, but not, the newest Symposium was a comedy too, since it also incorporates a replica of second-best kind off symposium revealed regarding the Protagoras-that where you’ll find poets expose, and you can where users “dispute more issues that cannot be dependent having any certainty” (347e17).

Ultimately, Alcibiades will come having-rather adequate-a great flute-woman (212c5-e3; examine 176e6-7). And even though she will not play, this lady arrival inaugurates the fresh new then decline of one’s symposium to the some thing a lot more like the form of symposium reviled on Protagoras due to the fact “an excellent symposium regarding well-known, serious fellows… just who, unable to entertain both the help of its individual talk, establish the expense of flute-females, and shell out a large amount to learn the fresh voice of one’s flute rather than their speak” (347c4-d2). This is the section of satyr-enjoy in the Symposium-satyr graphics is repeated when you look at the Alcibiades message.